News analysis ·

Stablecoin payments vs FedNow: how firms pick a rail

Money20/20 speakers say banks are slow to use new payment rails. We map how a firm picks between stablecoins, instant payments, ACH and checks.

Black-and-white photo of operators at check-processing machines in an old bank office, beside green and ink ticket stubs and a transit-line map scrap.
Photo: Hellström, Yngve / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (cropped)

On Monday, speakers at Money20/20, the payments conference held in Las Vegas, said banks and companies are still slow to use newer payment rails such as stablecoins and FedNow, Payments Dive reported. The panel described fatigue at banks, old software and unused data fields. This article looks at how a company actually chooses a rail, and who carries the risk on each one.

What the panel said

Amy Burr, chief product and relationship officer at Federal Reserve Financial Services, set the tone. In her view, end customers do not care which rail carries a payment. They want money to arrive reliably and fast. Yet many banks she talks to resist adding another system to their technology stack. "I spend a fair amount of time talking to financial institutions that just don't want another thing", Burr said, according to Payments Dive.

Her example was ISO 20022, a messaging standard that lets a payment carry rich, structured data. Fedwire, the Fed's large-value funds service that carries trillions of dollars daily, switched to it last year. Banks are only starting to use what it offers. Burr said banks and corporates are not filling in all the data fields, which leaves her somewhat pessimistic about programmable money.

The market around them has grown. Payments Dive cited McKinsey data showing yearly global payments revenue of $1.7 trillion in 2020 and $2.6 trillion last year.

How the money moves on each rail

A payment rail is the path money takes between payer and payee, with its own rules for speed, cost and finality. Sam Aarons, chief technology officer of Modern Treasury, told the panel to treat rails as a menu. Older options still have a place, he said, including low-cost ACH and even paper checks. He expects check volume in the United States to shrink but not to disappear.

In plain terms, the main options work like this:

  • Check: paper moves first, money follows later, and the payee waits while the check clears.
  • ACH: payments travel in batches between banks. It is cheap, but funds are not instant and some payments can be returned after the fact.
  • Instant payments such as FedNow: money moves between bank accounts in seconds, at any hour, and the transfer is final once sent.
  • Stablecoin: a token that tracks the dollar moves on a blockchain, so it can cross borders overnight without waiting on correspondent banks.

Irfan Ganchi, a senior vice president of product management at Circle, said the right choice depends on where the sender and receiver are and what each rail can do. A large multinational might move funds to its foreign units overnight by stablecoin, he said, while paying local suppliers through instant payments. Aarons added that big companies do not see stablecoins and fiat as an either-or choice. They use both, in different amounts.

What are stablecoin payments, and who wants them?

Stablecoin payments are transfers made with a dollar-linked token instead of a bank transfer. The receiver ends up holding the token, not a bank deposit. That is why Ganchi stressed receiver preference. A ride-share driver in Indonesia may want USDC, Circle's stablecoin, to hold dollars, while a driver in the US may simply want fiat in a bank account. A platform paying both has to support both rails, and convert between them.

Rules and risks: who carries the loss

Each rail moves risk to a different party. With a check, the payee carries the risk that it bounces. With ACH, a payment that looked settled can come back, so the receiving business carries return risk for a while. With instant payments, the transfer is final, which helps the payee but shifts fraud risk to the sender and the sending bank, because a mistaken or tricked payment is hard to pull back.

A stablecoin holder carries a different risk again. The token is only as sound as the issuer and the reserves behind it, and it is not a bank deposit, so deposit insurance does not apply. If the issuer fails or cannot redeem at par, a holder can lose money. A business that keeps stablecoin balances also needs a way to turn them back into dollars when it pays bills.

Data is a quieter risk. Aarons said tools that attach context, such as receipts, to payments already exist but are rarely used, likely because of decades-old software. His own American Express account shows purchases without receipts. When fields stay empty, staff must match payments to invoices by hand, and errors and disputes cost more to sort out.

What to watch

The panel pointed to adoption, not technology, as the bottleneck. Signs worth watching are whether banks start filling in the richer ISO 20022 data, whether more banks offer FedNow to business clients, and whether firms that pay workers abroad add stablecoin payouts next to bank transfers. Payments Dive noted that Money20/20 is owned by Informa, its own parent company.

Sources

Written by AI from the sources above and published automatically: before release, a script confirms every figure against the sources and checks for copied text. No editor reviews it. Treat it as background reading, not financial advice.

← All posts