News analysis ·
Fed debit fee cap struck down: who pays for fraud now
An appeals court vacated the Fed's 21-cent debit swipe fee cap. We trace how the fee flows and who carries fraud and fixed costs next.

On Monday, three judges sitting on the Eighth Circuit appeals court vacated the Federal Reserve's 21-cent cap on debit card swipe fees, Payments Dive reported. The judges said the Fed counted costs that Congress never meant it to count. This article looks at how a debit fee moves between merchants, networks and banks, and who may end up carrying fraud losses and the fixed costs of card programmes if the cap is rewritten.
What the court decided
The dispute goes back to April 2021. That is when Corner Post, a convenience store and truck stop in Watford City, North Dakota, sued the Fed to lower what it pays on debit transactions. U.S. District Judge Daniel Traynor struck down the Fed's fee rules in August 2025. The St. Louis-based appeals panel has now upheld that decision. Traynor himself joined the Eighth Circuit after Senate confirmation in July, but he did not sit on this panel.
The core question was about the Durbin Amendment, which Congress added to Dodd-Frank in 2010. According to Payments Dive, the judges read it as allowing the Fed to weigh an issuer's marginal cost of each transaction, but not the fixed costs of running the business. The panel put it bluntly: the Fed should sort costs properly and "Not just pick a number and hope it is close enough for government work."
The court did leave the Fed some room. Fees do not have to match marginal cost exactly, and the Fed may use a proxy, possibly average variable cost, as long as it reasonably tracks what issuers actually spend per transaction.
How the money moves in a debit swipe
Interchange is the fee a merchant's side of the transaction pays to the bank that issued the customer's card. When a shopper taps a debit card, the merchant's acquirer, the firm that handles card acceptance for the store, sends the payment through a card network to the issuing bank. The issuer approves it, the funds move at settlement, and the issuer keeps the interchange. The merchant receives the purchase amount minus that fee and other processing charges.
Under Regulation II, adopted in 2011, the Fed set the issuer fee ceiling at a base of 21 cents, with 0.05% of each purchase added, with an extra one-cent allowance for fraud prevention. The cap applies only to banks and institutions with $10 billion or more in deposits. Smaller issuers sit outside it.
The cap was built from a mix of costs. The court said it included fixed bank costs for authorization, clearance and settlement, plus network processing fees, spending on fraud prevention and losses from fraud itself. That mix is exactly what is now in question.
Who carries fraud and fixed costs
This is the part the ruling changes most. Today a slice of every capped debit fee helps the issuer pay for fraud losses and for the systems that authorise and settle payments. If a new rule may count only transaction-specific costs, some of those expenses can no longer be recovered through interchange. They do not disappear. Someone still pays them.
There are three places the cost can land. Issuing banks can absorb it and earn less on debit. They can recover it from cardholders through account fees or fewer free features. Or, if fraud costs are treated as outside the fee, banks may push harder on merchants through chargebacks, the process that reverses a disputed card payment and moves the loss back to the store. Which path dominates is not set by this ruling. It depends on how the Fed writes its next rule.
Both sides have already framed the stakes. The Merchants Payments Coalition called the decision a win for stores and shoppers. Doug Kantor, who is the top lawyer at NACS, the convenience store trade group, urged the Fed to write a replacement rule that complies with the law. Six bank and payment groups, including the Electronic Payments Coalition, the American Bankers Association and America's Credit Unions, said they were deeply disappointed. They argued large retailers kept past Durbin savings without lowering prices, and that cheaper fees would shift costs onto banks, credit unions and consumers.
What to watch next
The Fed's next step matters most. The cap is meant to be reviewed every two years, yet the Fed proposed its first revision only in October 2023, a cut in the base fee of about 30% to 14.4 cents. It has not acted on that proposal since. A Fed spokesperson declined to comment on the ruling or on where the 2023 plan stands.
There is also a second case. The bank groups pointed to Linney's Pizza vs. Federal Reserve, pending in the Sixth Circuit, where a Kentucky federal court ruled for the Fed last year. Two appeals courts reading the same statute differently would leave banks and merchants unsure which cost rules apply.
- Whether the Fed revives, rewrites or drops its 2023 proposal.
- How any new rule treats fraud losses and the one-cent fraud allowance.
- Whether issuers change debit account fees or dispute practices in response.
Sources
- Payments Dive, 26 Oct 2026
Written by AI from the sources above and published automatically: before release, a script confirms every figure against the sources and checks for copied text. No editor reviews it. Treat it as background reading, not financial advice.